My Splendid Concubine

"My Splendid Concubine" (MSC) and "Our Hart" combined as one novel.

All Reviews and Awards for both novels.

2011

Return to "My Splendid Concubine" Home Page

 

January

4 of 5 stars  on Amazon of MSC's 2nd edition
Jan. 9
Hope
*1 review with 1 helpful vote


NOTE: Near the end of January, I posted a five-star review of Amy Chua's memoir on Amazon and left comments on the Amazon Forum of Amy Chua's "Battle Hymn of the Tiger Mother" supporting Amy Chua's parenting methods.

I have had conflicts on the forum with several of Chua's most ardent critics, who often vote that my comments are not helpful, which "may" explain the rash of one and two-star reviews of my work starting February 2011.
My Amazon Review of "Battle Hymn of the Tiger Mother" posted on January 25, 2011

February

1 of 5 stars  on Amazon of MSC's 2nd edition
Feb. 22
colorado outback
* 2 reviews with 1 helpful vote

March

5 of 5 stars  on Amazon UK of MSC's Kindle edition
March 23
Linds71 (UK)
* 2 reviews with 3 helpful votes


5 of 5 stars  on Amazon of MSC's 2nd edition
March 28
Kiara Quinn
* 3 reviews with 17 helpful votes

April

2 of 5 stars  on Amazon of MSC's 2nd edition
April 3
Darrell L. Peck
* 12 reviews with 12 helpful votes


4 of 5 stars  on Barnes & Noble.com of MSC's 2nd edition
April 3
Share the Word


5 of 5 stars  on Amazon of MSC's 2nd edition
April 9
Cheryle Peloni
*3 reviews with 3 helpful votes


A Writer's Digest judge rated "Our Hart" 4.5 of 5 on a scale of 1 to 5 with 1 meaning "poor" and 5 meaning "excellent".

The judge wrote, "The book is meticulously researched and the author's enthusiasm for his subject is evident.… The author has an ear for natural-sounding dialogue, making OUR HART and engaging read… readers who enjoy vicariously experiencing other times and culture will find OUR HART a fascinating journey."
April 11

Commentary of the Writer's Digest Judge


 

 


2 of 5 stars  on Amazon of MSC's 2nd edition
April 26
Eastside Girl
* 1 review with no helpful votes


3 of 5 stars - Amazon for "Our Hart"
April 14
Ms. Arlene R. Schiek "anonymous reader"

1 review with no helpful votes

May

1 of 5 stars on Amazon of MSC's 2nd edition
May 30
KiKi D.
* 1 book review  

June

2 of 5 Stars  on Amazon of MSC's 2nd edition
June 5
 
Evern "Avid reader"
* 7 reviews with 4 helpful votes


2 of 5 Stars  on Amazon of MSC's 2nd edition
June 5
Georgia Reader
* 1 review with no helpful votes


5 of 5 Stars  on Amazon of "Our Hart"
June 16
Darlene
*141 reviews with 104 helpful votes

 

July

5of 5 Stars  on Amazon UK of MSC's Kindle edition
 
Jule 2
P. A. Beech (UK)
* 8 reviews with 80 helpful votes

August

 

September

 

 

October

 

 

November

 

 

December

 

 

Go To 2012

My Mother Would Have Burned This Book

Dissecting the Moral Duty of a Reckless and False Review

Return to "My Splendid Concubine" Home Page